What to know about propane tank installation and leasing in Sarasota, what drives cost, and how to compare the 31 local providers before you sign anything.
Propane tank installation and leasing covers the hardware side of running gas appliances on a property that isn't hooked to natural gas lines, which is most of Sarasota outside a few central pockets. A supplier sets a tank (above ground or buried), runs the gas line to your house, connects it to your regulator, and either sells you the tank outright or leases it to you as part of a fuel supply agreement. This category includes 31 businesses in the Sarasota area that handle sizing, permitting, installation, and ongoing tank ownership or lease terms.
Before choosing a supplier, get clear on a few things. First, tank size: a small 100-gallon tank suits a grill or fireplace, while a whole-house setup with a furnace, water heater, and range usually needs 250 to 500 gallons. Second, lease versus purchase: leased tanks often come with lower or no upfront install cost, but you're typically locked into buying propane from that supplier and may face a removal fee if you switch. Read the contract for minimum-gallon requirements, tank rental fees, and early-termination charges. Third, check whether the company handles permitting and inspection, since Sarasota County and municipal codes require setback distances and sometimes underground tank permits.
Our scoring weighs licensing, response times, contract transparency, and how installers handle permitting and follow-up service, so you can compare providers on more than price alone. See how we evaluate suppliers in our methodology, or jump straight to the ranked guide to Sarasota propane suppliers to see how these 31 businesses stack up.
Find propane tank installation & leasing in Sarasota in your area
No cost, no obligation. Tell us what you need and we'll connect you with suitable propane suppliers.
30 businesses, scored on recent reviews. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is propane tank installation & leasing, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.
Flanders Gas earns strong marks for quick refills, fair per-gallon pricing, and courteous staff; many customers praise service during hurricane season. Significant friction point: the business lacks online payment options, forcing customers through outdated phone-based billing processes.
Staff at this North Sarasota location consistently earn praise for friendliness and speed. Trucks, trailers, and storage are handled smoothly, with several reviewers noting quick turnarounds and cleanliness. However, U-Box customers report serious tracking issues and unmet delivery promises. Aaron, Juan, and Colstan are named multiple times for exceptional service. The 3.8 rating reflects strong execution on rentals and storage offsetting frustration with U-Box's corporate logistics. Individual staff effort matters here: reviewers thank specific employees by name for going beyond the standard transaction. Pick a staff member you trust if you're moving locally; proceed cautiously with cross-country U-Box moves.
Most customers praise fast service, fair prices, and a consistently helpful team. Staff like Melanie, Ann, Marie, April, and Jeff are named for their friendliness and responsiveness, and reviewers using automatic refill report smooth, efficient experiences. A small number report communication gaps during installs and occasional rudeness, but these accounts are outweighed by five-star testimonials spanning over a decade of loyalty.
Most renters report smooth pickups, well-kept equipment, and staff who go beyond standard service to meet deadlines. A handful of older complaints centered on last-minute cancellations and form-filling surprises, though stronger recent reviews suggest more reliable handling.
Suburban Propane attracts strong loyalty for individual technicians and customer service staff who take time with customers, deliver on time, and handle emergencies well. However, the company battles a pattern of uninvited deliveries, hidden charges, billing mistakes that take months to fix, chronic no-shows, and emergency wait times exceeding six hours, leaving many customers frustrated despite pockets of excellent service.
Find propane tank installation & leasing in Sarasota in your area
No cost, no obligation. Tell us what you need and we'll connect you with suitable propane suppliers.
Half the reviewers report smooth, friendly transactions with staff who go the distance; the other half describe billing snags, no-show technicians, and staff indifference when things go wrong. Best experience comes from simple truck or trailer rentals; installations and propane refills carry higher risk of confusion or frustration.
Long-standing family business built strong loyalty over years with dependable delivery and responsive emergency service. Recent reviews indicate they may have stopped offering propane or narrowed their scope, making current service availability unclear despite a strong track record.
One five-star review praises fast delivery, though evidence is limited to a single review. The business operates as a U-Haul propane refill station with published pricing for tank refills.
Review evidence is limited. Amerigas Propane Exchange lists propane delivery, tank installation, cylinder exchange, emergency service, and commercial supply across Florida; their website claims leak checks and tank recertification.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is too limited to characterize customer experience. The business claims to offer tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, leak checks, and commercial propane across Florida.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Find propane tank installation & leasing in Sarasota in your area
No cost, no obligation. Tell us what you need and we'll connect you with suitable propane suppliers.
Review evidence is too limited to characterize customer experience. The business claims to offer tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, leak checks, and commercial propane across Florida.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino Propane Exchange operates in Sarasota and handles propane tank exchanges, home delivery, and business delivery. Their website states propane delivery is available in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is too limited to characterize customer experience. The business claims to offer tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, leak checks, and commercial propane across Florida.
Review evidence is too limited to characterize customer experience. The business claims to offer tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, leak checks, and commercial propane across Florida.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.
Review evidence for this location is limited. Their website lists propane tank exchange, residential delivery, and commercial delivery services. They operate seven days a week in Park East, Sarasota.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Enquiries submitted through our forms may be passed to partner providers who can carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings are based solely on our published scoring method and are not affected by referral fees.
Last updated 2026-08-04