Best propane suppliers in Cape Coral

★★★★★4.5 (705 reviews)score 76/100

76/100

Tractor Supply pulls the top spot on volume of reviews (705) and a solid 4.5 rating, backed by named staff who reviewers single out for going the extra mile. It's less a dedicated propane shop than a farm store that happens to refill tanks, which explains why the propane side draws the most inconsistent feedback of anything it does well.

• Wide selection beyond propane, useful for one-stop errands
• Staff named repeatedly for helpfulness
• Open 7 days a week
• High review volume backs up the rating

Watch out: Propane refill service is flagged as unreliable, with repeat customers turned away for different reasons on different visits.

Services: emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane, autofill monitoring, residential propane delivery

★★★★☆4.4 (85 reviews)score 69/100

69/100

Lee County Plumbing & Supply earns the highest confidence score on this list thanks to consistent praise for staff (Dionne, Alba, Dee among others) who track down obscure parts rather than upsell new equipment. Propane tank exchange is offered, though it's a sideline to their core plumbing business rather than the main event.

• Staff go out of their way to source hard-to-find parts
• Fast service and honest troubleshooting advice
• Family-owned with a personable team
• Propane tank exchange available on-site

Watch out: Cash-only payment and disputed fill weights frustrate some regulars, and RV propane refills aren't offered.

Services: residential propane delivery, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane, propane tank installation

★★★★★4.8 (21 reviews)score 67/100

67/100

Paradise Propane posts the highest google rating of any mid-to-large volume business here (4.8 from 21 reviews), with owner Shaun and technician Hector both called out by name for service that goes beyond the basics. Delivery reliability is the standout theme, covering a service area that stretches from Fort Myers to Naples.

• On-time delivery consistently reported
• Owner personally involved in customer service
• Quick scheduling and response times
• Fair pricing noted by reviewers

Watch out: One recent review flags an hour-long wait with no answer during posted business hours.

Services: residential propane delivery, emergency propane service, propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane

★★★★☆3.9 (413 reviews)score 67/100moderate

67/100

BJ's Wholesale Club combines a gas station with warehouse retail, and its review volume (413) is the second-highest on this list. Fuel prices and quick checkout are the draw, even though the overall rating sits lower than the specialist propane names above it.

• Reasonable fuel prices
• Quick checkout and app-based payment
• Pump lines rarely crowded
• Friendly staff noted by reviewers

Watch out: Limited product variety and a layout some reviewers call disorganized.

Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane, autofill monitoring · Price: moderate

★★★★☆4.2 (93 reviews)score 67/100

67/100

RCS & Company draws five-star praise for technicians like Miguel, Daniel, Carlos, and Fernando, plus an owner (Rafael) who follows up personally after jobs. Set against that are recent complaints about steep diagnostic and repair costs and a warranty dispute that dragged on for a year, which pulls its standing down from where the technical praise alone would put it.

• Fast technician dispatch
• Skilled, professional installation work
• Owner follows up personally after jobs
• Bilingual staff (English and Spanish)

Watch out: Service charges run high, with diagnostic visits reported around $375-$500 and some repairs quoted over $4,000.

Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane

★★★★☆3.6 (75 reviews)score 58/100

58/100

Suburban Propane's individual technicians and office staff (Dave, Tryston, Susie among those named) get real praise for same-day installs and problem-solving. The company-level experience is more uneven, with a lower overall rating driven by scheduling and billing issues that a 3-star reviewer summed up as bureaucratic and expensive.

• Same-day installation and inspections available
• Named technicians praised for catching problems others miss
• Emergency and remote monitoring services offered
• Office staff willing to work around obstacles

Watch out: No-shows without notice, billing mix-ups, and week-long delivery waits are recurring complaints.

Services: residential propane delivery, emergency propane service, propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane

★★★★★4.5 (4 reviews)score 44/100

44/100

This Blue Rhino kiosk near Veterans and Santa Barbara gets a strong 4.5 rating, but with only 4 reviews it's a low-confidence pick worth treating as a convenience option rather than a vetted one. The one detailed review calls out competitive exchange pricing and fast service.

• Convenient Publix location
• Competitive tank exchange pricing

Watch out: Very few reviews exist, so the rating carries low confidence.

Services: residential propane delivery, autogas propane cylinder refill, propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane

★★★★★5 (1 reviews)score 39/100

39/100

This Amerigas location advertises a broad service menu, tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, recertification, leak checks, and fleet services, but rests on a single five-star review. Treat the service list as a starting point to confirm directly rather than a proven track record.

• Full range of advertised propane services
• Perfect rating from available feedback

Watch out: Only one review exists, so there isn't enough evidence to judge consistency.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

score 34/100

34/100

This Blue Rhino location serves the Burnt Store part of Cape Coral with daily tank exchange and delivery, but has zero reviews on record. It's included for area coverage and service claims rather than any proven customer experience.

• Operates seven days a week
• Tank exchange and home delivery advertised
• Serves both residential and business customers

Watch out: No reviews yet, so there's no customer feedback to evaluate.

Services: propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, emergency propane service

score 34/100

34/100

Another Amerigas branch in Cape Coral lists cylinder refill, tank exchange, delivery, installation, and fleet refueling across Florida. With no reviews to date, it sits on the list for its stated service breadth rather than a track record.

• Multiple propane services under one roof
• Commercial fleet refueling available
• Tank recertification offered

Watch out: No customer reviews exist yet to confirm service quality.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, autogas propane cylinder refill

score 34/100

34/100

This Amerigas hub stands out on paper for specialty services like AutoGas conversion and agricultural propane alongside standard tank exchange and delivery. National brand backing is the main selling point here, since review evidence is minimal.

• National chain backing
• Agricultural and fleet propane services
• Tank recertification and leak checks on-site

Watch out: No meaningful review history to confirm real-world service quality.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

score 32/100

32/100

This Amerigas location states it covers residential and commercial delivery plus emergency service, but has no reviews yet to back that up. It's worth a call for urgent needs, with the understanding that it's unproven on this list.

• Full-service exchange and refill claimed
• Emergency service listed
• Residential and commercial delivery offered

Watch out: Zero reviews on record, so service quality is unverified.

Services: propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, emergency propane service

score 32/100

32/100

This Blue Rhino location offers straightforward tank exchange and delivery for Cape Coral homes and businesses. It has no review history, so it's a fallback option rather than a vetted choice.

• Tank exchange and delivery available
• Serves both residential and business needs

Watch out: No reviews exist to confirm service consistency.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

score 30/100

30/100

The Home Depot propane exchange kiosk offers the convenience of a swap while running other errands, but there isn't enough recent review data to form a reliable read on service quality here.

• Convenient kiosk format for quick swaps
• Located inside a familiar big-box store

Watch out: Not enough reviews yet to gauge consistency.

Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane, autogas propane cylinder refill

score 30/100

30/100

A second Home Depot propane exchange kiosk in Cape Coral, included for the same grab-and-go convenience. Like its sibling location, there's no meaningful review base yet to assess it beyond the format itself.

• Convenient kiosk format for quick swaps
• Located inside a familiar big-box store

Watch out: Not enough reviews yet to gauge consistency.

Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane, autogas propane cylinder refill